According to city-data.com Oxbow, ND is one the wealthiest communities in Cass County and perhaps North Dakota.
Here are the 2013 estimated median household incomes for the following:
North Dakota: | $ 55,759 |
Cass County: | $ 52,015 |
Fargo: | $ 44,845 |
Oxbow: | $ 141,436 |
Despite the higher median income per household a different yarn is being spun by Oxbow’s elite who finagled big buyouts, yet, profess they are victims of circumstance in a process that has netted equity enrichment’s as high as 967.5 percent.
You have Oxbow Mayor Jim Nyhof living in government subsidized housing. Property that was annexed into Oxbow, ND just shortly prior to the $2.69 million Bartram estate buyout, and is now being rented for a mere $1,500 per month.
2016-06-09 | 970 WDAY Jay Thomas questions Jim Nyhof.mp3 | |
Whether one believes that Oxbow’s Elite “are” or “are” not driving the bus on this deal, is a matter of debate. What do you call intentional manipulation of “rules” for financial gain or equity enrichment?
Don’t forget, Oxbow Mayor Jim Nyhof was drafting 1 a.m. emails to city council members lobbying a concept that would allow every shareholder to walk away with a minimum of $ 27,000 each for their stockholder in a NONPROFIT corporation.
There were/are so many options that could have saved the state, county and city taxpayers a bundle when is comes to the Oxbow project. The OHB ring-dike-levee…, touted as a $65 million “all in price tag” which is currently passing the $75 million mark, forces the taxpayer into shelling out big bucks to provide equity enrichment for the Oxbow country club and homes. Was malfeasance really the intent behind the Cass County and Fargo flood taxes? The same taxes Fargo want voters to extend on the November ballot.
Albeit, there are a small handful of the 40 Oxbow property owners on the buyout list that wanted little from the process…, and there are those that bickered for every blade of grass.
Sadly, all 40 homes and course holes could have been addressed for around $10 million. The Fargo Dam and FM Diversion Authority (FMDA) could have spent $100,000 per home to construct a new foundation, provide utilities and relocation of the existing structures for around $4 million. They could have purchased 170 acres (130 acres for the golf course and 40 one acre lots for each home) for around $853 thousand. With the remaining dollars to landscape the golf course hole relocation’s.
But Oxbow’s Country Club elite were salivating over the high-end Robert Trent Jones plans and the FMDA was looking for a way to buy-off Oxbow and only had to dangle money.
One has to remember that Darrell Vanyo and others refused to compensate the Kindred School District for the annual $80k loss relating to Oxbow’s property tax reduction which was re-distributed to the remaining taxpayers within the district. Ironically, the $75 million spent thus far on Oxbow could have provided 937 years of compensation to the Kindred School District.
According to public FMDA records and information provided by AE2S, the buy-out list:
Oxbow Related Buy-Out List
(Click address below to view property)
Name | Previous Address |
New Address |
Cass County Valuation |
Buy-Out | Equity Enrichment |
% |
Andel | 810 Riverbend Rd | 787 Riverbend Rd | 213,600 | 1,330,318 | 1,116,718 | 622.81% |
Anderson | 337 Schnell Dr | 355 Trent Jones Dr | 229,800 | 837,199 | ||
Bartram | 5059 Makenzie Circle | Not Rebuilding | 553,300 | 2,708,777 | 2,155,477 | 489.57% |
Benson | 840 Riverbend Rd | 442 Trent Jones Dr | 273,400 | 935,071 | 661,671 | 342.02% |
Bindas | 813 Riverbend Rd | 449 Trent Jones Dr | 330,300 | 1,356,539 | 1,026,239 | 410.70% |
Brakke | 361 Schnell Dr | 764 Riverbend Rd | 321,000 | 757,849 | 436,849 | 236.09% |
Breen | 345 Schnell Dr | ( Left Oxbow ) | 258,600 | 485,572 | 226,972 | 187.77% |
Champ | 829 Riverbend Rd | 788 Riverbend Rd | 481,500 | 2,368,373 | 1,886,873 | 491.87% |
Debates | 848 Riverbend Rd | ( intend to stay ) | 361,700 | 2,302,898 | 1,941,198 | 636.69% |
Fisher | 357 Schnell Dr | 760 Riverbend Rd | 321,000 | 643,246 | 322,246 | 200.39% |
Goldsmith | 325 Schnell Dr | ( intend to stay ) | 203,000 | 811,137 | 608,137 | 399.57% |
Hakanson | 332 Schnell Dr | 421 Trent Jones Dr | 189,900 | 607,616 | 417,716 | 319.97% |
Hasbargen | 852 Rivergend Rd | Not Rebuilding | 358,300 | 1,222,600 | 864,300 | 341.22% |
Henry | 317 Schnell Dr | 409 Trent Jones Dr | 287,300 | 1,121,726 | 834,426 | 390.44% |
Huber | 744 Riverbend Rd | ( Left Oxbow ) | 283,900 | 346,263 | 62,363 | 121.97% |
Ingebrigtson | 353 Schnell Dr | 772 Riverbend Rd | 206,300 | 806,556 | 600,256 | 390.96% |
Jeff Pederson | 805 Riverbend Rd | 776 Riverbend Rd | 277,900 | 888,158 | 610,258 | 319.60% |
Jeziorski | 349 Schnell Dr | 761 Riverbend Rd | 153,600 | 616,718 | 463,118 | 401.51% |
Johnson | 817 Riverbend Rd | ( intend to stay ) | 278,000 | 935,133 | 657,133 | 336.38% |
Johnson | 338 Schnell Dr | 775 Riverbend Rd | 249,800 | 910,062 | ||
Kaspari | 17495 52nd St SE | Not Rebuilding | 476,800 | 813,352 | 336,552 | 170.59% |
Kautzman | 330 Schnell Dr | Not Rebuilding | 190,000 | 452,710 | 262,710 | 238.27% |
Kochmann | 329 Schnell Dr | 417 Trent Jones Dr | 358,000 | 1,087,247 | 729,247 | 303.70% |
Kuntz | 346 Schnell Dr | ( Left Oxbow ) | 267,500 | 512,971 | 245,471 | 191.76% |
Kuzas | 341 Schnell Dr | 351 Trent Jones Dr | 202,100 | 1,094,521 | 892,421 | 541.57% |
Leake | 844 Riverbend Rd | Not Rebuilding | 322,900 | 720,000 | 397,100 | 222.98% |
Losing | 752 Riverbend Rd | 768 Riverbend Rd | 268,200 | 976,182 | 707,982 | 363.98% |
Mathiason | 350 Schnell Dr | 769 Riverbend Rd | 229,100 | 764,991 | 535,891 | 333.91% |
Mattson | 328 Schnell Dr | 347 Trent Jones Dr | 143,800 | 647,141 | 503,341 | 450.03% |
McQuillan | 313 Schnell Dr | ( intend to stay ) | 165,300 | 724,738 | 559,438 | 438.44% |
Menze | 828 Riverbend Rd | Not Rebuilding | 367,700 | 960,000 | 592,300 | 261.08% |
Miller | 333 Schnell Dr | ( Left Oxbow ) | 89,100 | 104,088 | 14,988 | 116.82% |
Murphy | 334 Schnell Dr | 751 Riverbend Rd | 158,800 | 600,244 | 441,444 | 377.99% |
Nyhof | 336 Schnell Dr | ( intend to stay ) | 166,400 | 496,508 | 330,108 | 298.38% |
Pearson | 309 Schnell Dr | 325 Trent Jones Dr | 223,500 | 1,096,718 | 873,218 | 490.70% |
Podolak | 843 Riverbend Rd | ( intend to stay ) | 529,800 | 2,298,780 | 1,768,980 | 433.90% |
Rademacher | 821 Riverbend Rd | 434 Trent Jones Dr | 288,300 | 1,050,324 | ||
Retzlaff | 748 Riverbend Rd | 755 Riverbend Rd | 313,300 | 686,434 | 373,134 | 219.10% |
Rieger | 833 Riverbend Rd | 446 Trent Jones Dr | 374,400 | 1,369,738 | 995,338 | 365.85% |
Rustvang | 839 Riverbend Rd | Not Rebuilding | 550,900 | 1,779,000 | 1,228,100 | 322.93% |
Sauvageau | 326 Schnell Dr | Not Rebuilding | 139,300 | 496,508 | 357,208 | 356.43% |
Schneibel | 749 Riverbend Rd | 433 Trent Jones Dr | 271,100 | 1,044,845 | 773,745 | 385.41% |
Strei | 808 Riverbend Rd | ( under construction ) | 301,200 | 1,280,129 | 978,929 | 425.01% |
Talley | 321 Schnell Dr | 410 Trent Jones Dr | 264,200 | 961,008 | 696,808 | 363.74% |
Wold | 816 Riverbend Rd | 429 Trent Jones Dr | 239,500 | 924,505 | 685,005 | 386.01% |
Oxbow Country Club | 130 Oxbow Drive | 40 Club House Drive | 1,085,200 | 10,499,448 | 9,414,248 | 967.51% |
“Yellow” Estimated – Based Upon Average Oxbow Buyout | 364.32% | |||||
12,733,400 | 55,433,942 | 30,171,408 |
Why would any Fargo or Cass county taxpayer ever consider extending a multi-generational sales tax to provide welfare to the wealthy?
Should Cass County strip Oxbow of its city status and acknowledge it as the exclusive Oxbow Country Club community it is…?
Coming up next: Wealthy Welfare Part 4 – The “Agenda”
Views: 3701
Following the 2009 flood all the Oxbow flood homes were bought out. The above homes did not need buyouts because they were not even located in the flood plain!. Then, even though not in the flood plain or needing flood insurance, Cass County paid for a ring dike for Oxbow that was completed 2010 and designed by Houston Engineering – the same engineers doing the Diversion. That’s what communities that have median incomes of $140,000.00 – and political influence – get. That and 500% unnecessary buyouts. This is how Fargo’s leaders spend the 1/2 cent sales tax.
We live North of Oxbow, along the river, we were told by Houston engineering, that we wouldn’t have to sand bag until a ’45 Crest in Fargo! but with the dam in place they would put ‘5 on the main floor! That being said,do you think we would get a Oxbow style buyout?? Or eminent domain?
Jon,
It is very unfortunate that the FMDA is offering preferential treatment to Oxbow and leaving the remaining landowners in the proposed staging reservoir in limbo.
You have specific property rights and protections defined under either option.
It would be in your best interests to contact the following law firms that deal with eminent domain issues to ascertain your best course of action:
Garaas Law Firm
1314 23rd St S,
Fargo, ND 58103
Phone:(701) 293-7211
garaaslawfirm@ideaone.net
Rinke Noonan
1015 W St Germain St,
St Cloud, MN 56303
Phone:(320) 251-6700
http://www.rinkenoonan.com/contact-us/
Biersdorf & Associates
150 S 5th Street, Suite 3100
Minneapolis, Minnesota 55402
Phone: 866-692-5039
E-Mail: info@condemnation-law.com